PIMvendors

Knowledge Base · Core · · Updated 2026-11-21

Core · Guide

Food Claims and Their Evidence: What to Store in a PIM After the EmpCo Rules

A food pack makes more promises than its name: "low sugar", "organic", "vegan", "gluten-free", a Nutri-Score, a fair trade mark. Each is a claim with its own legal basis and evidence that must be valid on the day of sale. The same claim also sits in the webshop, retailer files and data pools, so one expired certificate can leave a wrong claim on every channel. This guide covers the rules per claim family and what to store per claim in a PIM. It is not legal advice: confirm the rules for each market with your quality or legal team. Claims and their evidence are one of the five product data challenges on our food and beverage hub.

The claim families and their legal base

Each family has its own rule and its own kind of evidence.

Nutrition and health claims

Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 covers nutrition and health claims in labelling, presentation and advertising, including food supplied to restaurants, hospitals and canteens, so foodservice product data counts too. A nutrition claim is only allowed if it is listed in the Annex and meets its conditions (Article 8): "low sugar" means no more than 5 g of sugar per 100 g for solids or 2.5 g per 100 ml for liquids. A health claim must be authorised and listed, with its conditions of use, in the EU Register of nutrition and health claims, and must come with statements such as the importance of a varied and balanced diet (Article 10). In the PIM, link each claim to its register entry and to the nutrient values behind it, so a recipe change triggers a new check.

Organic

Regulation (EU) 2018/848 applies since 1 January 2022 (the date was moved by Regulation (EU) 2020/1693). Terms such as "organic", "bio" and "eco" are reserved for compliant products, and processed food needs at least 95% organic agricultural ingredients by weight to use them in its sales name (Article 30). The label shows the control body's code number and, for prepacked food with some exceptions, the EU organic logo with "EU Agriculture" or "non-EU Agriculture" (Article 32). The operator needs a certificate that states its validity period, and must verify its suppliers' certificates (Article 35).

Sustainability and quality labels

Fair trade, animal welfare or sustainable fishing marks usually fit the EU definition of a sustainability label: a voluntary mark that promotes a product for its environmental or social characteristics. Since EmpCo such a label needs a certification scheme or a public authority behind it. Store the scheme, licence number, coverage and validity.

Nutri-Score

Nutri-Score is a voluntary front-of-pack score. In Germany, for example, its use is voluntary and requires the trademark owner's consent and compliance with its conditions (§ 4a LMIDV). The algorithm has been revised (see our Nutri-Score article), so store the score with the algorithm version, the calculation date and the nutrient values it came from.

Vegan and vegetarian

As of November 2026 there is no EU legal definition of "vegan" or "vegetarian". Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 lets the Commission adopt rules on suitability for vegetarians or vegans (Article 36(3)(b)), but its page on voluntary food information names only the gluten rules as adopted. Until then the claim must not mislead and must not be ambiguous (Article 36(2)). Store the definition or private scheme you follow and the supplier declarations behind it.

"Free from" claims

"Gluten-free" is regulated: no more than 20 mg/kg of gluten in the food as sold, and "very low gluten" no more than 100 mg/kg (Implementing Regulation (EU) No 828/2014). Other "free from" statements fall under the general rules: they must not mislead, nor suggest a special characteristic that all similar foods share (Article 7 of Regulation 1169/2011). All of them depend on allergen and ingredient data; see allergen data management in PIM.

Environmental claims

"Recyclable packaging", "climate neutral" or "deforestation-free" now fall under the EmpCo rules. Packaging claims draw on packaging data (PPWR packaging compliance and product data), and a "deforestation-free" line needs its own evidence next to the EUDR due diligence (EUDR and food product data).

What EmpCo changed on 27 September 2026

Directive (EU) 2024/825 (EmpCo) amends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive 2005/29/EC. Member states had to apply it from 27 September 2026 (Article 4). An environmental claim is any voluntary message, including text, images, labels, brand names and product names, that suggests a product is good or less harmful for the environment, or has improved over time. It adds twelve practices to Annex I of Directive 2005/29/EC, the list of practices banned in all circumstances. Seven concern durability, repair, software updates and consumables. These five matter for food claims:

  • Sustainability labels without a scheme (point 2a). A label needs a certification scheme with independent third-party monitoring, or a public authority behind it.
  • Generic environmental claims (point 4a). "Eco-friendly" or "green" are only allowed if the trader can demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance: the EU Ecolabel, an officially recognised EN ISO 14024 type I ecolabel, or top performance under other EU law. A claim whose specification is clear and prominent on the same medium is not generic (recital 9).
  • Whole-product claims for a part (point 4b). For example "made with recycled material" when only the packaging is (recital 11).
  • Offset-based neutrality claims (point 4c). "Climate neutral" or "climate compensated" based on offsetting instead of the product's actual lifecycle impact (recital 12).
  • Legal requirements sold as a feature (point 10a). Presenting what the law requires of every product in the category as a distinctive feature of your offer.

A claim about future environmental performance also needs a detailed and realistic implementation plan with measurable, time-bound targets, regularly verified by an independent expert (Article 6(2)). For product data, the key word in point 4a is "demonstrate": the evidence has to be on file before the claim goes out.

Transposition in Germany and the Netherlands

Germany transposed EmpCo with the Third Act amending the Act against Unfair Competition (Drittes Gesetz zur Änderung des UWG) of 12 February 2026. The bans are numbers 2a, 4a, 4b, 4c and 10a of the UWG annex, and the act entered into force on 27 September 2026.

The Netherlands transposed it with the Implementatiewet richtlijn betere duurzaamheidsinformatie voor consumenten (Stb. 2026, 152), which amends Book 6 of the Civil Code, including articles 6:193a, 6:193c and 6:193g. An entry-into-force decree put it into force on 16 July 2026; the ACM, which supervises the rules, names 27 September 2026 as the start of the stricter rules.

  1. 6 March 2024

    EmpCo published

    Directive (EU) 2024/825 appears in the Official Journal.

  2. 19 February 2026

    Germany publishes its UWG amendment

    The amending act appears in BGBl. 2026 I No. 43.

  3. 16 July 2026

    Dutch act in force

    The Implementatiewet (Stb. 2026, 152) enters into force under the decree in Stb. 2026, 204.

  4. 27 September 2026

    EmpCo rules apply

    The new bans apply in every member state.

  5. 4 November 2026

    Green Claims Directive listed for withdrawal

    The Commission's 2027 work programme lists the proposal for withdrawal.

The dated rules timeline on our food hub puts EmpCo next to the PPWR and EUDR dates.

The Green Claims Directive: not law

The proposed Green Claims Directive (COM(2023) 166) would have set detailed rules for substantiating explicit environmental claims. As of November 2026 it has not been adopted, and the Commission's 2027 work programme of 4 November 2026 lists it among the proposals it intends to withdraw within six months. Plan on EmpCo and the national laws. For product data the conclusion is the same: a claim you cannot back with a document on file should not be published.

What to store per claim in the product record

Treat a claim as its own record, linked to every product that carries it, not as a text field on the product. One certificate often covers many items, and one item often carries several claims.

FieldWhat it holds
Claim typeThe family: nutrition, health, organic, label, Nutri-Score, vegan, free from, environmental
Exact wordingApproved text per language and market, with any required statement ("Low sugar", "Suikerarm", "Zuckerarm")
ScopeProduct, ingredient, packaging or company
Legal basis or schemeThe rule or scheme the claim relies on, such as the Annex of Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006
Evidence and issuerThe document that proves it and who issued it
Certificate numberLicence, certificate or control body code
Valid from and untilValidity of the evidence
Depends onAttributes that must stay true, such as sugar per 100 g or allergen fields
MarketsWhere the claim may be shown
ApprovalWho approved which version, and when
ChannelsPack, webshop, retailer files, data pool

Then let rules do the checking:

  • Block on missing or expired evidence. Every product that carries such a claim fails validation.
  • Warn before expiry. Alert the claim owner well before the valid-until date.
  • Re-check on change. When a value under "Depends on" changes, the claim goes back to review.
  • Respect market and scope. No claim in a market it is not approved for, and no whole-product wording for a packaging-only claim.
  • Flag generic wording. Send any claim that uses terms such as "green", "eco-friendly" or "climate neutral" to legal review.

It is the same governance as for other critical fields; see product data quality and governance.

A change-controlled path for claims

  1. Propose the claim in the PIM

    Marketing enters wording, scope, markets and channels in the PIM, not in an email or artwork file.

  2. Attach the evidence

    Quality or regulatory links the certificate, register entry, test report or implementation plan, with issuer, number and validity dates.

  3. Validate automatically

    Rules check the evidence and its dates, markets, scope, wording and the attributes the claim depends on.

  4. Approve per market

    Legal or regulatory approves the wording for each market. The PIM records who approved what and when.

  5. Publish to every channel together

    Artwork brief, webshop, retailer files and data pool all take the claim from the same approved version.

The path also runs in reverse. A certificate expires, a recipe change pushes sugar above the threshold, a supplier loses its organic certificate: the PIM sets the claim to withdrawn and every feed drops it in the same run, including the GS1 data pool, because a claim gone from your webshop but still in a retailer listing still reaches consumers. The artwork team gets a change request, and the audit trail shows when the claim stopped.

Checklist: testing a PIM on claims

Use these points to select a PIM or test your current one:

  • Claims are entities with their own fields, evidence and expiry dates, linked to many products.
  • Wording is held per language and market, with the markets where each claim is allowed.
  • Validation blocks publishing on missing or expired evidence and re-checks claims when nutrient, allergen or ingredient data change.
  • Approval names the approver and date, and the audit trail keeps every wording version.
  • One query answers "which products, in which markets and channels, carry this claim?"
  • Feeds to the webshop, retailer files and data pools take claims from the same approved data; see PIM vs PXM vs syndication tools.

In a demo, ask the vendor to expire one certificate live and show what happens on each channel. For the full food record, see PIM for food and beverage.

Where to go from here

Both tools are free and independent of any vendor.

Not sure you need a PIM yet?

A short check that shows whether a dedicated PIM helps your catalog, or whether spreadsheets and ERP still do the job.

Check if a PIM fits

Ready to compare vendors?

Answer questions about your scale, sector and must-haves and get a ranked shortlist.

Build my vendor shortlist

Frequently asked questions

What is EmpCo and when does it apply?

EmpCo is Directive (EU) 2024/825, which amends the EU rules on unfair commercial practices. Member states had to apply it from 27 September 2026. It bans generic environmental claims without recognised excellent environmental performance, offset-based "climate neutral" claims and sustainability labels that are not based on a certification scheme or set by public authorities.

How have the Netherlands and Germany transposed EmpCo?

Germany amended its Act against Unfair Competition (UWG) with a law published on 19 February 2026 and in force since 27 September 2026. The Netherlands amended Book 6 of the Civil Code with the Implementatiewet richtlijn betere duurzaamheidsinformatie voor consumenten (Stb. 2026, 152). The ACM enforces the Dutch rules.

Is the Green Claims Directive in force?

No. As of November 2026 it is still the proposal the Commission tabled in 2023. The Commission's 2027 work programme lists it among the proposals it intends to withdraw within six months.

Which health claims may I use on food?

Only health claims authorised under Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 and listed in the EU Register of nutrition and health claims, used under their conditions of use. The label must also carry the statements required by Article 10(2), such as the importance of a varied and balanced diet.

Is there an EU legal definition of vegan?

Not as of November 2026. Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 allows the Commission to adopt rules on suitability for vegetarians and vegans, but it has not done so. Until then the general rules apply: the claim must not mislead and must not be ambiguous.

What should a PIM store for each claim?

The claim as its own record: type, exact wording per language and market, scope, legal basis or scheme, evidence and issuer, certificate number, validity dates, markets, approval and channels. Link it to every product that carries it and block publishing when its evidence is missing or expired.

What happens to a claim when its certificate expires?

The claim should come off every channel at the same time: webshop, retailer files, data pools and the next pack artwork. A PIM can set the claim to withdrawn, fail validation on the products that carry it and send the change to every feed in the same run.

Diagnostic

Do you actually need a PIM?

Run the complexity index before you budget software or hire an SI.

Start assessment

Budget

Model a first-pass TCO

Translate catalog shape into a three-year cost range in under ten minutes.

Open cost calculator